Oh, and apparently they were supposed to sing “Total Eclipse of the Heart,” so Allyssa shares her disappointment with every number because it isn’t (but should be) that song. Schue, Principal Figgins, and Brad the Piano Player. You won’t want to miss our cringe-worthy, IMPROMPTU session of Holly Holiday and April Rhodes’s version of Smash-Marry-Kill featuring Mr. This week on Gleeboot, we mourn the loss of our sanity while discussing yet another more natural end to the bananas show that is Glee. Gleeboot, Season 5 Episode 13 - “New Directions”